We audit Google Ads accounts for Canadian businesses every month, and the remarkable thing is how repetitive the waste is. Different industries, different budgets, same twelve leaks. None of them are exotic; most are Google’s own defaults doing what defaults do, which is favour Google’s revenue over yours.
Here are the twelve, each with its fix. Read them against your own account; if you recognize four or more, an audit will pay for itself in the first month.
1. No Conversion Tracking (or Broken Tracking)
The most expensive mistake wears a disguise: the account looks fine, spends fine, reports clicks. It just cannot say which clicks became customers, so every optimization is a guess. We find missing or misfiring tracking in a large share of self-managed accounts. The fix: Track the actions that are money: calls, form submits, bookings, purchases. Test each one yourself, watch it appear in Google Ads, and only then judge anything else in this list.
2. Broad Match With Smart Bidding and No Guardrails
Broad match tells Google “show my ad for anything you consider related,” and Google’s definition of related is generous with your budget. Paired with automated bidding and no data, it burns hardest in month one. The fix: Start with phrase and exact match on your money keywords. Introduce broad match only after conversion data exists to steer it, and never without the next fix in place.
3. A Thin (or Empty) Negative Keyword List
“Free,” “DIY,” “jobs,” “salary,” “course,” “what is”: searchers typing these are not buying, but they click. Accounts with no negative list routinely leak 15 to 30% of spend to them. The fix: Build a negative list before launch, then mine the search terms report weekly and add new negatives every time. This one habit outperforms most bid tinkering.
4. Sending Every Click to the Homepage
The homepage is your reception desk; ads should skip it. A searcher who clicked “dental implants cost Mississauga” and lands on “Welcome to our practice” starts hunting, then leaves. The fix: One tightly matched landing page per campaign theme, with the searched-for thing above the fold and one obvious action. This is the single biggest cost-per-lead lever in most accounts.
5. Default Location Settings
Google’s default includes people who showed “interest in” your area, which is how a Brampton plumber pays for clicks from another province researching Brampton. The fix: In location options, target “presence” (people in or regularly in your locations), and check the locations report monthly for surprises.
6. Ignoring the Search Terms Report
The keywords you bid on and the searches you actually paid for are different lists, and only one of them is real. The fix: Fifteen minutes weekly in the search terms report: add converting terms as keywords, add junk as negatives. Accounts that do this compound; accounts that do not calcify.
7. Set-and-Forget Syndrome
Google Ads is not a crockpot. Auctions shift, competitors launch, ads fatigue, and an untouched account decays with perfect quietness while the invoices stay identical. The fix: A weekly management rhythm: search terms, budget pacing, ad tests, and one deliberate experiment. If nobody has that rhythm, that is what professional management is actually for.
8. Testing Nothing (One Ad Per Ad Group)
A single ad is an opinion; two ads are an experiment. Accounts running one tired responsive search ad per group have no way to get better. The fix: Two RSAs per ad group minimum, genuinely different angles (price vs speed vs trust), and let performance retire the loser monthly. Feed real headlines, not fifteen versions of your business name.
9. Chasing Clicks Instead of Quality Score
Low Quality Scores quietly tax every auction you enter: worse positions at higher prices. Ignoring the score while raising bids is paying the tax with a smile. The fix: Tighten the triangle of keyword, ad copy, and landing page relevance; the mechanics are in our guide to Quality Score. Score improvements cut real CPCs.
10. No Ad Extensions (Assets)
Sitelinks, callouts, call assets, and location assets make your ad physically larger and answer questions before the click. Skipping them donates screen space to competitors. The fix: Load every relevant asset type: four-plus sitelinks, six-plus callouts, call and location assets for local businesses. Ten minutes of setup, permanent CTR benefit.
11. Judging the Account on the Wrong Number
Clicks, impressions, and even CTR are activity metrics. Businesses have closed profitable accounts because “the CTR seemed low” and kept wasteful ones because traffic looked busy. The fix: Judge on cost per lead against what a customer is worth, full stop. The benchmark context for Canadian advertisers is in our Google Ads cost guide.
12. Quitting (or Scaling) at the Wrong Moment
The twin errors of month two: shutting off an account just as its data starts working, or tripling budget into a structure that has not earned it. Both come from reading noise as signal. The fix: Give a new account 90 days and judge the trend of cost per lead, not the week. Scale in steps of 20 to 30%, watching whether efficiency holds, and fix leaks before feeding budget; scaling a leaky account just buys a bigger leak.
What a Leaky Account Looks Like in the Wild
A composite from real audits, numbers rounded: a home services company spending $3,000 a month, frustrated after six months. Tracking counted form fills but not calls, and this business lives on calls, so half its actual leads were invisible (mistake 1). Broad match plus no negatives meant the search terms report, never opened, contained “handyman course,” “repair jobs hiring,” and a neighbouring city (mistakes 2, 3, 5, 6). Every ad pointed at the homepage (4), one ad per group had run unchanged for a year (7, 8), and the owner judged everything on clicks, which looked great (11). No single mistake was fatal. Together, roughly $1,300 of the $3,000 was buying nothing every month, quietly, with excellent click-through rates. The point of the story is not that the owner was careless; it is that the account looked normal from the driver’s seat. Leaks do not announce themselves; they have to be gone looking for. That is exactly what our paid ads audit does, and if you run Performance Max, read our plain-English PMax guide as well.
The 30-Day Cleanup Order
If you recognized your account above, fix in this sequence, because each step makes the next one measurable. Week one: conversion tracking rebuilt and tested, calls included; nothing else matters until the scoreboard works. Week two: search terms triage and a proper negative list; location settings to presence. Week three: landing pages matched to your top two campaign themes, even simple ones. Week four: second ads into every group, assets loaded, and a recurring 15-minute weekly slot in your calendar for the search terms report. Thirty days, mostly evenings, and the account you judge in month two is finally the account you are paying for.
The Quick Self-Audit
Score your account honestly: tracking verified this month? Negative list growing weekly? Every campaign pointing at a matched landing page? Location set to presence? Two ads testing per group? Cost per lead known and trending? Six yeses means you are in the healthy minority. Three or fewer means the account is very likely paying for several of the mistakes above simultaneously, and the compounding is not in your favour.
Frequently Asked Questions
Almost always mistakes 1, 3, or 4: tracking not counting the leads you do get, junk searches clicking through, or a homepage landing experience losing them. Check in that order.
The leaks stack: weak negatives commonly waste 15 to 30% alone, and accounts carrying several of the twelve can waste half their spend. Which is why an audit that costs a few hundred dollars regularly finds four figures in monthly leakage.
Ninety days with the mistakes above fixed. Ninety days with them unfixed proves nothing except that leaks leak.
Numbers 1, 3, 5, and 10 are absolutely DIY-able in an afternoon with patience. The weekly rhythm (6, 7, 8) and the landing page work (4) are where owners usually decide their time is worth more than the fee.
Structure, tracking integrity, search term waste, Quality Score patterns, landing page match, and settings traps, delivered as a findings list with dollar estimates attached. Ours is free and you keep the findings either way: Paid Ads Audit and Strategy.







